According to West Midlands Police, the offences began in June 2025. During the abuse, Ayeni reportedly recorded some of the attacks on his mobile phone and threatened to release the videos if the victim reported him to the police, claiming the recordings would prove that the encounters were consensual.
The woman eventually reported the abuse in March 2026, leading to an investigation by specialist officers from the police force’s Rape and Serious Sexual Offences team.
Ayeni was sentenced at Warwick Crown Court on November 10, 2026.
In her victim impact statement, the woman said the pastor’s position had made her trust him, adding that the experience had severely affected her mental and emotional well-being and made it difficult for her to trust others.
She also described the courage it took to report the abuse, saying she feared being judged or disbelieved.
Detective Sergeant Evie Griffiths of the police force’s Public Protection Unit described the offences as horrific, noting that Ayeni had abused the trust placed in him to commit the crimes.
The pastor has also been placed on the sex offenders register indefinitely.